Get Off My Lawn

I can't tell if he's laughing or crying.

Derek: Ricky Gervais’ Theatre of Cruelty

Image

It is with disappointment that I heard that the original Netflix production Derek is starting its second season.

The show is written and produced by Ricky Gervais, a man I have, up this point, found to be funny. This show is a huge misstep. Derek is a caretaker of sorts in a senior citizens’ home. At no time is it overtly presented that Derek is developmentally delayed, but he obviously is, and embodies all of the worst, and most offensive, stereotypes that, sadly, are often associated with the developmentally delayed:

He walks about with his mouth open and his jaw set at a bizarre angle in what I assume is supposed to demonstrate some facial deformity.

His hair is unwashed, greasy, and cut in a fashion that could only be acquired through a home barber kit.

His clothes are ill fitting, out of date, and drab, and he wears his pants far too high.

I think I’ve mentioned before that I work in group home for handicapped adults, so I can speak with some experience about why the portrayal of Derek is so misguided. First and foremost is the idea that someone with a developmental disability can’t desire to look their best–that somehow an interest in hygiene and fashion doesn’t not exist in this population. I can assure you that it does. Interest in clothing, hair styles, cologne, perfume, body image, and behaviour that at times might seem shallow or vacuous as it focuses on the surface is very much alive and well in the population of the developmentally delayed as it is in any other segment of “normal” society. And this is fantastic. This is normalization, something talked about and strived for on a daily basis among people who work in the field. The idea that someone who has a developmental disability has no concern for their appearance, how they smell, weight gain, and how others perceive them is prejudice in its purest form.

Image

His co-worker and best friend is the maintenance man and bus driver. When we first meet him, Derek asks him as he passes by in front of the camera if he’d like to take part in the show. The maintenance man launches into an indictment of his own life, saying how ashamed he is to look the way he does, make the kind of money he makes, and then, most embarrassingly of all, that he works in a home for seniors. An insinuation here is that because Derek’s co-worker is not developmentally delayed, he can have the good sense to be ashamed of who he is and what he does. He is mean, at one point telling the camera that the residents just fill their rooms with shit and they are given too much space. He throws a painting in the garbage instead of repairing it for a resident. Later in the show, in a feeble attempt at redemption, he does repair the keepsake and hangs it on the wall. But this does not redeem his original attitude. But it isn’t all bad, as he explains; he can get things like his eyeglasses off the residents who die. Jesus wept.

Derek’s other friend and co-worker continually scratches at the front of his pants because he has a fungus on his crotch. And he collects autographs. Enough said.

Image

But perhaps saddest of all in this “comedy” is that elderly people are treated as props, the butt of jokes that fail, and stereotypes (an old person forgets someone’s name! Oh my god that is funny! I think I just shit my pants!), and they are, at least in the episode I watched, the source of all things gross and humiliating. The only use the residents seem to have is as bait to attract family members to visit and hopefully provide a dating pool for the employees.

I thought the British Office was brilliant, and I loved Life’s Too Short, the show Gervais produced for HBO. I do understand why, as an artist, he wants to attempt the new and not merely repeat what has worked in the past. But in this particular effort he has failed. Derek is not funny; the characters are insultingly simplistic. What Gervais has done is create a theatre of cruelty, not only for the hateful portrayal of the vulnerable, but for the viewer at home who had high hopes.

The Ringer

If you have an interest in seeing a depiction of  the developmentally delayed that is funny, charming, a little edgy, and has heart, I recommend The Ringer, starring Johnny Knoxville and featuring actual people with developmental disabilities. That’s right, a movie starring Johnny Knoxville is absolutely the best, and most accurate, depiction of a culture few people have access to. You see fully formed individuals who are mouthy, sharp, egotistical, and sarcastic, as well as sensitive, caring, and sophisticated, like the developmentally delayed people who are my clients and friends. This movie will definitely give you a far better and much funnier idea of this segment of society than Derek could ever hope to do.

The Ringer 2

Categories: Uncategorized

Tags: , , , ,

20 replies

  1. I love your critique. I shout an amen in your direction!

    Like

  2. I normally like Ricky Gervais, too, but I’m glad I stayed away from this one. Thank you for dispelling some of these horrible stereotypes. Tomorrow I head to New England to attend a memorial service for my step-sister’s son, a remarkable man who happened to be developmentally delayed, and whose life was taken too quickly. Were I to see the show ‘Derek,’ I’d be fuming. Thanks for the heads up on the Johnny Knoxville film. I’ll have to check it out. I kind of like that guy. (Did you see Bad Grandpa? Oy.)

    Like

    • Thank you Carrie and I’m sorry for your loss. I have not seen Bad Grampa but I fully intend to. We’ve watched all the Jack Ass movies and loved them. My wife and I and some friends were turned away from the theatre when Jack Ass 3 came out because some of us did not have proper proof of age ID, even though we were all clearly over 18. Hahaha. We were not sure if we should have been miffed or say thanks.

      Like

  3. It is so NOT cool to make fun of other human beings. Mimicking and sarcasm are the two lowest forms of humour in my book. I only watched one episode and I have to say I was so disappointed with RG. 😦

    Like

    • I know eh? We were so let down. My wife was a little turned off by him a couple of years ago when she bought some of the childres books he wrote thinking they’d be funny but they full of sexual innuendo. I was willing to give him the benifit of the doubt but after Derek I don’t think I’ll be much of a fan.

      Like

  4. I am usually okay with crude things and all…but this sounds a bit odd. If it had a positive message and represented them accurately but in a humorous yet friendly way….I think that would have been the stronger route! In the same manner as The Ringer actually…as you pointed out. While I do not recall if I liked that one…I must say that I am a big fan of Bad Grandpa…just had too!

    Like

  5. I think you’re confused. Derek doesn’t wear lousy clothes and look unclean and act like he’s slow because he’s developmentally delayed; it’s because he’s British.
    Oh, and I agree, stereotypes are cruel and insensitive. No one should use them.

    Like

  6. I don’t know that I would find entertainment in inaccurate and ignorant stereotypes about developmentally delayed people.
    Good for you for speaking out!

    Like

    • Thanks Samara. Well, like I said, I’m not a humourless hyper politically correct stick-up-his-ass kind of guy, but I thought this was throwing rocks at a fairly defenceless group. There are sooooooo many other people, riddled with self-inflicted gunshot wounds, to redicule. Thanks for stopping by.

      Like

  7. Nice post, John! The first season was way better than the second, but I think if anything, we’re being shown that Gervais should just chill out on Derek. At least for now, that is. Move on and see what hits his creative-bug next.

    Like

  8. Agree with you. There is nothing funny. It is only a display of bad taste and tactlessness.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s